Watalappan Recipe: An Easy Sri Lankan Coconut Custard
An easy watalappan recipe for first timers. Sri Lankan coconut custard with kithul jaggery, steamed on the stove, plus what to swap if you can't find it.
Every Eid, a plastic box came over from the neighbors with a wobbly brown square of watalappan inside. We ate it cold, standing at the fridge door. For years I assumed it took someone's grandmother and a secret.
It doesn't. This watalappan recipe is eggs, coconut milk, dark jaggery and cardamom, steamed in a pot for about 45 minutes. The hard part is waiting for it to chill.
If you've never had it, think of a flan or caramel custard, but darker, with a smoky palm sugar taste and coconut all the way through. You'll also see it spelled watalappam, vattalappam and wattalapan. Same pudding.
The watalappan recipe
You'll need (serves 6)
- 250 g kithul jaggery, about 1 1/4 cups once grated and packed
- 3 tablespoons water
- 1 cup (240 ml) thick, full fat coconut milk
- 5 large eggs
- 1/2 teaspoon ground cardamom, or the seeds of 6 pods, crushed
- A pinch of ground nutmeg
- A pinch of salt
- A small handful of roasted cashews, to finish
How to make it
- Make the syrup. Grate or chop the jaggery and put it in a small pan with the water. Melt it over low heat, stirring, then pour it through a sieve, because jaggery often has grit in it. Leave it until it's just warm to the touch, about 15 minutes.
- Mix the eggs. Whisk the eggs with the salt, cardamom and nutmeg until no streaks of white are left.
- Combine. Stir the coconut milk into the cooled syrup, then pour that slowly into the eggs, stirring as you go.
- Strain it. Pour everything through a sieve into a heatproof dish or steel bowl. Fill it about three quarters full and cover tightly with foil.
- Steam it. Put a small rack or an upside down saucer in a big pot and sit the dish on it. Add hot water to about a quarter of the way up the dish. Put the lid on and keep it at a gentle simmer for 40 to 50 minutes, topping up the water if it runs low. Mine rattles on the saucer the whole time, which at least tells me it's simmering.
- Check it. The edges should be firm and the center should still wobble a little. A knife pushed in near the middle should come out without liquid egg on it. Cups take less time, about 25 to 30 minutes.
- Chill it. Cool it on the counter, then refrigerate for at least 4 hours. Overnight is better. It firms up as it gets cold, so don't panic if it looks soft when it comes out of the pot.
- Finish. Scatter the cashews on top just before serving, so they stay crunchy.
Don't have a pot that fits? Use the oven
Set the foil covered dish in a deep roasting tray and pour hot water halfway up its sides. Bake at 350°F (180°C) for 35 to 45 minutes, until it's set with a slight wobble in the middle. A lower oven takes longer but gives a smoother custard, if that's what you're after.
Kithul jaggery is the whole flavor
Kithul jaggery comes from the sap of the kithul palm. It's the dark, smoky block you see at Sri Lankan markets, called kithul hakuru here, and it's what makes watalappan taste the way it should.
Some blocks sold as kithul are mixed with cane sugar. The real thing tastes smoky and a little like coffee, and it isn't just sweet. Buy from someone you trust, and taste a corner if they'll let you.
If you're outside Sri Lanka, try these, roughly in this order.
- Kithul jaggery from a Sri Lankan or South Asian store. It keeps for months, so it's worth ordering online too.
- Gula melaka or dark palm sugar. Malaysian and Thai stores carry it, and it's the closest in taste.
- Dark brown sugar. Use the kind with molasses in it. You'll lose the smoke, but the color and depth stay close enough.
Skip pale cane jaggery and white sugar. The custard comes out a washed out beige, and it tastes like a sweet egg pudding, which I found out the one time I tried it.
About the coconut milk
Use thick milk, the first squeeze if you're making it fresh, which we call miti kiri. Canned full fat coconut milk works well, so shake the can first. If you use powder, mix it stronger than the packet says. Light coconut milk gives you a watery custard.
Should watalappan have holes?
This is the question I see argued about most, and both answers are right.
Some people want it smooth all the way through, like a flan. Others want it full of tiny holes, with dark syrup pooling in them when you cut a piece. I'm on the holes side, because the syrup is the best part. Plenty of people I know would call that overcooked.
You get to choose. Holes come from air in the eggs and from more heat.
- For a smooth custard, stir the eggs without beating in air, strain the mixture twice and keep the water at the lowest simmer you can manage.
- For the honeycomb kind, whisk the eggs hard until they're foamy, and steam at a steady simmer.
Whichever you choose, keep the foil tight. Steam dripping back onto an uncovered custard leaves a wet, pockmarked top.
Why did my watalappan go wrong?
It's grainy or has bits of cooked egg. The syrup was too hot when it met the eggs, or the steam was too fierce. Let the syrup cool properly next time, and turn the heat down. Straining catches some of it, but it can't fix eggs that have already scrambled.
It's watery or won't set. Either it needs more time or the coconut milk was too thin. Put it back in the pot for ten minutes and test again. Remember that it firms up in the fridge, so check it again once it's cold before you give up on it.
It's too sweet. This recipe is on the sweet side, as watalappan usually is, and Sashinka found my first batch too much. Drop the jaggery to 200 g if you want it less sweet. I wouldn't go lower than that, because you'd start to lose the flavor.
It tastes eggy. Add more cardamom next time, and don't skip the nutmeg or salt.
There's a pale layer on top. That's coconut cream that has risen to the surface. It's harmless, and it tastes good.
Where watalappan comes from
Most accounts say Malay people brought it to Sri Lanka in the 1700s, under Dutch rule, and that it probably grew out of serikaya, a Malay steamed custard made with palm sugar. Nobody seems fully sure, and even the name has a few competing stories.
What isn't in doubt is who keeps it going. Watalappan belongs to Sri Lanka's Muslim community first, and it's a fixture at Eid and weddings, shared with friends and neighbors, which is how I got to eat it as a kid. Everyone else has picked it up since, and now you'll find it on restaurant menus and at family parties all over the island. My Muslim friends' mothers still make it better than I do, and I've stopped trying to compete.
How to serve it and how long it keeps
Serve it cold, in small portions. It's rich, and a small square goes a long way. Bring the whole dish to the table if you've made it in a nice one, or use individual cups if you'd rather skip the cutting.
It's a good choice for a party, since it has to be made the day before anyway. I'd put it on the table at a girls night in, and a glass of cinnamon and kithul iced tea goes well beside it, as long as you don't mind a lot of kithul in one sitting.
Keep it covered in the fridge for up to four days. Don't leave it out for long, especially in a hot kitchen, because it's full of eggs and coconut milk. Don't freeze it either, since the texture goes watery when it thaws.
Questions people ask about watalappan
Is watalappan dairy free and gluten free?
This version is both, because it uses only coconut milk and no flour. Check the labels if you're using a coconut milk powder, since some contain milk protein.
Can you make watalappan without eggs?
The eggs are what set it, so an eggless version is a different dessert. I've seen recipes that use agar or cornstarch. I haven't made them, so I can't tell you how close they get.
Can you halve the recipe?
Yes. Use 3 eggs and half of everything else, and start checking it at about 25 minutes.
Before you go
Make your first one in small cups. They cook faster, you can test one without cutting into the whole thing, and if the first batch is a little off you've still got dessert.
If your family makes it with something different, like cloves or a splash of rose water, tell me about it, because every house here seems to have its own version. There are more sweet things coming to the desserts section.
xo, Roots & Roam
You might also like
Food & Drinks
Ceylon Iced Tea: 6 Easy Drinks You Can Make at Home
Six easy Ceylon iced tea drinks from my Colombo kitchen, from classic lemon to ginger lime and cinnamon kithul, plus tips so it never turns bitter.
Food & Drinks
Easy Overnight Oats Recipe: 5 Flavors for Busy Mornings
An easy overnight oats recipe with the simple ratio I use every week, plus 5 flavors including Milo, mango coconut and cinnamon kithul. Five minutes tonight.